Top Rated Crib Mattress: 5 Best Options Compared

Imagine this: it’s 3am and you’ve tried everything to get your baby to go back to sleep. No matter what you try, nothing works. She just keeps crying away every time you place her back down on her crib mattress. And then suddenly the problem dawns on you. The mattress you chose for your baby’s crib can be just as important as the structure of the crib itself. So you want the top rated crib mattress

best rated crib mattress

​A sturdy crib won’t be much help to a small baby sleeping on an uncomfortable mattress. But you also need one designed to keep your sleeping child safe from harm in the form of bacteria, allergies, and improper structure, throughout the night.

​If you’re looking for mattresses to compliment the crib you’ve purchased, here’s a look at five of the best crib mattresses on the market to ensure your child is getting the best sleep possible.

What Is The Best Crib Mattress?

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Hypoallergenic material

Waterproof vinyl cover

High density for excellent support

Lead free

Fits all standard cribs

Dream on Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Interwoven coils for support

Antibacterial mattress

Waterproof material

Resistant to mold

Lightweight for mobility

Kolcraft Cozy Soft Portable Crib Mattress

100% hypoallergenic polyester

Designed for portable use

Thick top layer for firmness


Waterproof for ease of cleaning

Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Anti-static material

Compliant with federal standards of anti-flammability


Lead free for paramount safety of the child

Dream On Me 3 Portable Crib Mattress

Fits all standard port cribs

Up to federal standard on anti-flammability

Domestically manufactured in the USA

Antibacterial material for sensitive users

Baby Crib Mattress Reviews

  • Hypoallergenic material for sensitive skin
  • Waterproof vinyl cover for easy cleaning
  • Fiber core with high density for excellent support
  • Lead free for paramount safety
  • Fits all standard cribs

If you’re looking for a mattress that retains its shape, cleans easy, and doesn’t leave stains, then this is the mattress for you and your baby. This is one of the easiest mattresses to clean and puts a real focus on fighting against the growth of mold and bacteria thanks to its excellent material. The mattress’ great asset is perhaps how long lasting it is and how much use it provides. Though it’s not immune to all the possible pitfalls of a mattress, it’s one of the best bets out there to avoid them.

The mattress has been proven to not only last across years, but last across generational use, often being passed down between kids. It also has a track record of helping those with respiratory issues during the night. It’s also completely free of harmful chemicals that can be found in the fibers of mattresses.

There’s not much bad things going on for this model. There’s no functional or design flaws, and it’s been proven to handle a lot of use without giving into tears or losing shape. Though there is a case-by-case issues, the general consensus is that if you take care of this mattress, it will, in turn, take care of your baby. Take advantage of the cleaning ease of this mattress to avoid the growth of mold and bacteria.

If you are wondering what is the best crib mattress, this is an easy choice. It’s ranked high on several Amazon lists and personal user lists, and that’s for a good reason. Its long-lasting durability makes it an excellent choice for any first time parent looking for a reliable mattress. It’s got a solid reputation and is one of the best mattresses for cleaning ability, mold resistance, and hypoallergenic qualities for sensitive babies.

  • 80 interwoven coils for incredible support
  • Antibacterial mattress for allergy sensitive children
  • Waterproof material for easy cleaning procedures
  • Resistant to mold and mildew build up
  • Lightweight for mobility, if needed

This is a USA-made mattress designed for optimum comfort for any baby or toddler. Its durability of use has been proven not only in repeat child use, but even pets find it a comfortable bed if you’re looking for one. The quality you get for the price is pretty astounding, and it is a proven favorite for plenty of toddlers out there looking for a good night’s sleep. The mattress holds up over the years through repeat use and possibly even different generations of kids.

However, while it is designed to be used by young children of several ages, its use seems to serve best for toddlers. While it boasts firmness, it does tend to lean towards the softer side, which makes it a bed better suited for an older child as firm mattresses are the preferred style for an infant. The softness will catch and hold a toddler well, but might prove to be a tad dangerous for smaller children.

And in the realm of softness, the mattress cover can be susceptible to damage from overuse because of that. But it all depends on how you use it and how well you take care of it during its use that determines damage. If properly taken care of, the mattress will provide nights and nights of solid sleep for any toddler. Unfortunately the mattress might lose shape over time.

Great mattress for the price but suited better for toddlers and up despite being marketed for cribs as well. Its lightweight makes it suitable for use in mobile situations and the amount of interwove coils make it a very durable mattress for repeat use by a slightly older child. An easy pick for the top rated crib mattress.

  • 100% hypoallergenic polyester for those with sensitive skin
  • Designed for portable use if needed
  • Thick top layer for firmness, designed for a small baby
  • Reinforced to be tear-resistant
  • Waterproof for ease of cleaning
  • 100% USA made product

Kolcraft is a highly trusted company in the mattress business, going all the way back to the 1940s with renowned supportive and user-friendly mattresses and pads. Today they keep up that legacy of excellent mattresses for infants and toddlers. And this Cozy Soft crib mattress is no different from that long line of quality. A flat, safe surface designed for softness to the touch and firmness for sleep, it’s one of the most trusted mattresses you can find.

This is a mattress that is, first and foremost, designed to be used in portable cribs. This means it focuses on being movable, user-friendly, and fairly lightweight. It’s easy to move, fits in a variety of different portable frames (though it is noted it is not designed for use with portable cribs exceeding 24.5’’ by 38.5’’). Many have found great success in using it within a child’s Pack n Play.

One possible pitfall, however, is in how thin the overall mattress is. To help make it portable, it’s not nearly as cushy or thick as the typical crib mattress used for home use. While that may take some level of comfort away, it allows for extended use in a variety of crib options for a child. Overall it seems to be put to best use for quick naps or comfort of play and not for long, soundless nights of sleep in a home bed.

A word of caution as well: this mattress isn’t a perfect fit for every portable crib size out there. As the manufacturer points out, you’ll need to make sure you’re monitoring your child if the mattress leaves a gap between itself and the edge of the crib. So take those dimensions and the size warning seriously, because putting in a mattress too small for a frame can be very dangerous to a sleeping child.

Best used for portable crib situations but doesn’t sacrifice too much comfort for mobility. It’s one of the softest mattresses for a mobile crib and retains its shape better than most competitor options. Also highly tear resistant with durable, thick top layer for years of use and movement.

  • Anti-static material
  • Compliant with federal standards of anti-flammability
  • Anti-microbial
  • Completely lead free for paramount safety of the child

One of the first things many people seem to notice about this mattress is its ability to become incredibly compact for shipping and mobile needs and how well it “fluffs” out within 48 hours of unpacking. Letting the foam within the mattress expand to its full form results in the best possible sleep (and the safest) for any little human looking to call this mattress home each night. To make it more impressive, this mattress is anti-flammable, antibacterial, and antimicrobial.

Based on several uses as a bed for large dogs, it’s clear this bed is durable to wear, for even the most rambunctious child. It’s resistant to tears and retains its shape incredibly well over the years and over the use. The price is also a solid plus for this mattress, especially considering the amount of mattress you get and all the amenities it comes with after it bursts into shape upon unwrapping.

Although, it’s not without some flaws. Though it’s rare, there is a chance the mattress won’t completely fluff in corners or portions, which can result in the need to do some manual fluffing yourself. For this, you’ll want to take advantage of the factory warranty as the lack of fullness of the mattress after opening might be a manufacturer issue. For the most part the design performs well without a hitch and forms into an incredibly fluffy and durable mattress for any baby or toddler.

This unique design is available for a good price and a solid amount of durability. It’s unique packaging and ability to transform out into a full, soft, and fluffy bed is unique and proven to be a useful facet, despite some instances of the mattress not quite fluffing out completely into proper shape.

  • Fits all standard port cribs
  • Up to federal standard on anti-flammability
  • Domestically manufactured in the USA
  • Antibacterial material for sensitive users

The feel of this mattress has been described as “cloud-like”, which is a pretty nifty feat for a portable mattress. What it really strives to do is to prove that comfort and portability can, in fact, exist in the same mattress. Though it is firm and durable, it’s more concerned with making the experience incredibly comfortable for the baby. It’s completely free of dangerous chemicals, like lead, and is designed to perfectly cradle small children in comfort for a safe and restful place to catch some z’s, or just relax while on the go.

Pac n’ Play sizes sheets cover the mattress nicely to complete the soft and comforting environment. This mattress also balances the firmness needed for sleeping infants with the softness they also crave. And like many of these crib beds, it has been tested for the ultimately durability thanks to repeat use as a dog bed. It stands up to wear, which is perfect for moving it between different types of environments. And all the while it retains the cloud-like softness it advertises.

While the quality of the mattress is undisputed, it has been noted that the mattress is a bit small for some Pac n’ Play models, which can create a hazard. So before buying one and installing it, make sure you look at the dimensions carefully and make sure it is compatible with the size of your portable crib and free of any hazards. As with some of the mattresses above, ensuring dimensions are compatible is paramount to safety for your child. Always avoid having gaps between the mattress and the wall of the crib as a fall in can result in injury or even suffocation if the child is asleep.

An excellent mattress combining firmness and softness made for most mobile crib units. Somewhat small compared to some larger mobile crib units and can run the risk of being too small and possibly hazardous. This is easily avoided by doing research and ensuring the measurements for crib and mattress line up.

Top Rated Crib Mattress: The Final Word

So there you have it. Several choices for crib mattresses across the board; whether you’re looking for a portable mattress for a Pac n’ Play or you want a more permanent, longer lasting mattress for your child’s crib each night. New infants and even seasoned toddlers all need a perfect mattress to ensure they get the best sleep they can for their growing bodies and growing minds.

Hopefully these baby crib mattress reviews were helpful. Have a question about the top rated crib mattress? Leave a comment below and we'll get right back to you.​